Why you can trust TechRadar
We spend hours testing every product or service we review, so you can be sure you’re buying the best. Find out more about how we test.
Light spoilers follow for all six episodes of A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms.
HBO’s Game of Thrones (GoT) franchise could use a boost right now. The eponymous show’s incredibly divisive finale is still being discussed to this day, and while House of the Dragon‘s (HotD) first season repaired some of the damage its forebear’s last-ever episode caused, its most recent eight-part installment was similarly not without criticism for narratively spinning its wheels.
The hope, then, is that A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (AKotSK) will course-correct HBO’s Thrones-Verse once more – and it does. It may lack Thrones‘ apocalyptic stakes and the ongoing fiery family feud that permeates HotD, but HBO’s latest retelling of another George R.R. Martin book series more than makes up for it with a rib-tickling, haunting, and triumphant tale of beating the odds.
A knight’s tale
Based on The Hedge Knight, the first entry in Martin’s ‘Dunk and Egg’ novella trilogy, and set a century before Game of Thrones, AKotSK tells the story of Ser Duncan the Tall (Peter Claffey) – or, to use his less formal moniker, Dunk.
After burying his deceased mentor and hedge knight – the term used for a wandering, chivalrous sword-for-hire – Ser Arlan of Pennytree (Danny Webb), Dunk travels to Ashford Meadow to try and win its latest tourney and prove his worth as a noble warrior. There, he encounters Egg (Dexter Sol Ansell), an unruly but intelligent boy who implores Dunk to let Egg be his squire. Thus begins a fellowship that, unbeknownst to the pair, will forever etch their names into Westeros’ history.
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms isn’t averse to dialling up the humor when required
AKotSK‘s premise – one that positions it as a dirt-covered folktale (think of street-level scenes from GoT and HotD, and you’ll get the idea) – sets it out as an unusually intimate story compared to its more illustrious and narratively epic siblings, but that’s intentional.
It doesn’t possess the multi-House fight for The Iron Throne or the grimdark, apocalyptic events of Game of Thrones, nor does it come close to matching the destructive intrafamilial warfare on display in House of the Dragon. And, sure, high-ranking clans – the Targaryens and Barathons being the most noteworthy – feature throughout AKotSK, so characters from privileged backgrounds have increasingly prominent parts to play in the HBO Max TV Original.
Nonetheless, even with its more introspective, grounded narrative, AKotSK is no less dramatic, action-oriented, tragic, or amusing than its larger-scale brethren. In fact, where the last of those descriptors are concerned, it’s no contest that AKotSK is the funniest live-action adaptation of Martin’s literary works so far.
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is no less dramatic, action-oriented, tragic, or amusing than its larger-scale brethren
Whether it’s slapstick moments, black comedy, toilet humor, fish-out-of-water moments involving Dunk, or the clever use of smash cuts and cutaway shots in present-day and flashback sequences, A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms isn’t averse to dialing up the amusement when required.
The jokes are never overused and don’t outstay their welcome, either. Instead, they enliven and brighten proceedings, especially in early episodes as Dunk navigates socially awkward interactions, and they allow AKotSK to strike a more optimistic, lighter note than HBO’s other Thrones interpretations.
As I alluded to earlier, that’s not to say that AKotSK eschews what’s made previous Game of Thrones adaptations so absorbing.
Amid the whimsy and hilarity, an underlying tension is always gently simmering in the background, but only threatens to boil over from the high-fantasy drama’s midpoint. Here, AKotSK takes a sobering, emotionally-strung turn that not only significantly raises the stakes for Dunk, but also douses the series in a tragic light, with multiple tear-jerking moments that hit me hard despite the limited time I’d spent with its supporting cast. If it’s adrenaline-fueled action, suspense-filled spectacle, and moving melodrama you’re after, episodes 4 through 6 deliver the goods in spades.
Hedge your bets
Before those episodes arrive, A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms relies on the endearing, odd-couple partnership between its protagonists to drive its comedy-drama-based story forward.
At times akin to a two-hander, AKotSK wastes no time introducing its protagonists to each other – the pair crossing paths less than 10 minutes into its premiere. In doing so, it dispenses with the sluggish, exposition-filled opening that some viewers might deem necessary for a series that’s not only set in a new period of the Thrones timeline, but also introduces numerous new characters to those who haven’t read Martin’s literary works.
It’s clear from Dunk and Egg’s first encounter that Claffey and Ansell have great chemistry and rapport
It’s clear from Dunk and Egg’s first encounter, though, that Claffey and Ansell have great chemistry and rapport. Highlighting this efficacious, buddy cop-like relationship as early as possible gives us a charming albeit at times testy friendship to invest in and rally around as the show unspools its secrets and other shock-value moments.
Ansell is as paramount to the successful portrayal of Dunk and Egg’s dynamic in a live-action capacity as his senior scene-partner. Indeed, with a performance and acting capabilities that belie his tender years, Ansell faithfully captures Egg’s boisterousness, foolhardiness, cleverness, and impunity with ease.
Peter Claffey delivers a towering performance in every sense of the word
It’s Claffey, though, who truly steals the show as AKotSK‘s naive yet chivalrous loner.
An unassuming hero despite his evident stature, Dunk is a righteous man in a not-so-righteous world whose worldview is constantly tested by external forces. Initially ostracized by those at the Ashford Meadow tourney and plagued by bouts of impostor syndrome throughout, he’s a seemingly oafish individual whose imposing frame hides a deep vulnerability that Claffey inhabits with real poise and emotional precision.
It’s a towering performance in every sense of the word and, while I know fans will get a kick out of his portrayal from the outset, I can already see the superlatives that’ll be thrown Claffey’s way after his bellowing, scene-jolting speech in episode 4’s final minutes, and tear-jerking moments in AKotSK‘s final two chapters.
It would be remiss of me not to spotlight members of the supporting cast, too. Daniel Ing’s Lyonel Baratheon steals every scene he’s in, while Finn Bennett’s Aerion Targaryen is a pantomime villain of menacing proportions. Bertie Clavell’s Baelor Targaryen, Sam Spruell’s Maekar Targaryen, and Shaun Thomas’ Raymun Fossoway are also captivating presences whenever they appear.
If I have one major gripe about A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, I wish more time had been spent building out certain character arcs and relationships. Great though it is, not enough screentime is devoted to Dunk and Egg’s bond. I’d similarly point the finger at some of its eclectic supporting cast of characters, too, all of whom operate on Dunk’s orbit but, where some individuals are concerned, are given short shrift from a character development perspective.
I wish more time had been spent building out certain character arcs and relationships
At 30 to 40 minutes per episode, AKotSK‘s short runtimes – compared to GoT and HotD – might make its week-to-week release model unbearable and/or draw complaints from viewers who may feel short-changed by their brevity.
However, I didn’t mind the pace at which its plot progressed, nor did each episode’s length feel curt in conjunction with the short story that The Hedge Knight tells. In fact, I’d say the addition of original storytelling components actually increases the duration of certain chapters, and – whisper it so book purists can’t hear me say this – bolster its narrative.
My verdict
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is a undeniably triumphant underdog tale. What begins as an unsuspecting story about two misfits fated to find each other soon evolves into a rip-roaring crowd-pleaser that’ll have you running the emotional gamut, particularly in its latter half.
Okay, its primary theme – that being how friendship and co-operation trumps all – is clichéd. Nevertheless, given the fractured state of our own world, in which division runs riot across the sociopolitical spectrum, it’s a timely message to heed.
With HBO recently announcing that AKotSK will return for a second season, we’ll witness more of Dunk’s rags-to-riches story down the road. And frankly, if it’s as good as AKotSK‘s debut outing, I’ll watch everything the Game of Thrones prequel’s lovable underdogs get up to on their history-defining adventures.
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms premieres on Sunday, January 18 (North and South America) and Monday, January 19 (everywhere else). Learn more about it ahead of launch via my guide to A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms.
