Date: October 20, 2025
Former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher has called for a major change in the Reds’ starting lineup following their 2–0 defeat to Manchester United at Old Trafford — a result that has sparked heated debate among fans and pundits alike.
Carragher, who has never shied away from criticizing underperforming players, described one Liverpool star’s display as “shambolic” and insisted that manager Arne Slot must take action before the team’s title hopes take further damage.
Carragher’s Harsh Verdict
Speaking on Sky Sports after the game, Carragher said:
“You can’t keep playing someone who’s making the same mistakes week in, week out. If Liverpool are serious about challenging for the title, changes have to be made immediately.”
While Carragher didn’t initially name the player, sources close to the show confirmed that his criticism was directed at Liverpool right-back Trent Alexander-Arnold, whose defensive lapses once again came under the spotlight.
Alexander-Arnold Under Fire
United’s wingers repeatedly exposed Liverpool’s right flank, with Marcus Rashford and Alejandro Garnacho exploiting space behind Alexander-Arnold throughout the match. The defender was also at fault in the build-up to United’s opening goal, failing to track back quickly enough to stop the cross.
Fans on social media echoed Carragher’s frustration, with #DropTrent trending on X (formerly Twitter) shortly after the final whistle.
One fan wrote, “Love Trent for his creativity, but his defending is killing us in big games. Enough is enough.”
Liverpool’s Defensive Woes Continue
Liverpool’s defeat means they’ve now gone three games without a clean sheet, raising concerns about their defensive structure under Slot. Despite a strong attacking lineup, the Reds’ backline has struggled to cope with high-tempo opposition.
Carragher added:
“Liverpool need stability at the back. Sometimes it’s not about talent; it’s about discipline and awareness — and right now, Trent’s positioning is costing the team.”
What’s Next for Liverpool?
With crucial fixtures coming up against Chelsea and Arsenal, Slot faces a difficult decision: stick with Alexander-Arnold or give Conor Bradley a chance to prove himself.
Liverpool fans will be watching closely to see how the manager responds — and whether Carragher’s criticism sparks a much-needed defensive reset.
